Character Profile

Penny Sinclair

Played by: Caitlin FitzGeraldShows: We Were LiarsSeasons: 1

Penny Sinclair is a main cast character in We Were Liars. Portrayed by Caitlin FitzGerald, their story unfolds across 1 season and 8 episodes on RecapHub.

Character Overview

About Penny Sinclair

Penny Sinclair is a main cast character in We Were Liars. Portrayed by Caitlin FitzGerald, their story unfolds across 1 season and 8 episodes on RecapHub.

Story Role

Role in the Story

supporting

Portrayed By

Actors Who Play Penny Sinclair

Caitlin Fitzgerald — Primary

Media

Photos & Videos

No character media available yet. Photos and videos will be added in a later update.

Character Importance

Role Significance

Billing: Top-billed main character
Role: main cast
Shows: We Were Liars
Seasons: 1
Episodes: 8

Episode Timeline

Appearance Timeline

Season 1

E1 — Tell Me Sweet Little Lies (Jun 18, 2025)
E2 — Wrap Her Up in a Package of Lies (Jun 18, 2025)
E3 — The Ties Were Black, the Lies Were White (Jun 18, 2025)
E4 — The Fourth of You Lie (Jun 18, 2025)
E5 — Lying Together in a Silver Lining (Jun 18, 2025)
E6 — When Lies Gives You Lemons (Jun 18, 2025)
E7 — Everybody Knows That the Captain Lied (Jun 18, 2025)
E8 — My Friends Are Lying in the Sun (Jun 18, 2025)

Shows & Episodes

Appearances

We Were Liars

Season 1 · 8 Episodes Cast Played by Caitlin FitzGerald Role: Main Cast